
True Crime Time for November 21, 2026 | Susan Smith Denied Parole Again: 30 Years After Murdering Her Sons
21 Nov 2026 · 49:57
Opening — Justice for Victims
- Woody encourages listeners to follow Real Life Real Crime on social media and the Real Life Real Crime Community app.
- He highlights solved cold cases and the importance of families finally receiving justice.
- He recognizes Barbara Johnson, Lynn Rollins, and Stephanie, who helped bring Courtney Coco's story to listeners.
- Woody reminds the Lifers to continue submitting tips and supporting ongoing investigations.
On This Day in True Crime — November 21
Woody reviews significant crimes and historical events associated with November 21:
- 2016 — Emma Walker: The Tennessee teenager was murdered, and her former boyfriend, Riley Gaul, became the focus of the investigation.
- 2006 — Pierre Gemayel: The Lebanese cabinet minister and member of parliament was assassinated, sparking political unrest.
- 2004 — Wisconsin hunting murders: Chai Vang shot eight hunters during a confrontation involving a tree stand, killing six and wounding two.
- 2001 — Anthrax attacks: Ottilie Lundgren died from inhalation anthrax, becoming the fifth and final fatality associated with the 2001 anthrax mailings.
- 1986 — Iran-Contra affair: Woody discusses Oliver North, Fawn Hall, the destruction of documents, and the federal investigation.
- 1985 — Jonathan Pollard: The former U.S. Navy intelligence analyst was arrested for passing classified information to Israel.
- 1973 — Watergate: An unexplained 18½-minute gap in a subpoenaed White House recording became part of the Watergate scandal.
- 1963 — Robert Stroud: The prisoner known as the Birdman of Alcatraz died after decades of incarceration.
- 1959 — Alan Freed: The radio personality was dismissed amid the music industry's payola controversy.
- 1993 — Sandra Costilla: Her remains were discovered in New York; Woody discusses the case in connection with the Gilgo Beach investigation.
Wisconsin's 2004 Hunting Murders
- Woody returns to the November 21, 2004, shootings in Sawyer County, Wisconsin.
- He shares his personal experience hunting on public and private land.
- Chai Vang, a hunter from Minnesota, entered private hunting property and occupied a tree stand.
- Members of the hunting party confronted Vang about trespassing.
- The confrontation escalated into gunfire, leaving six hunters dead and two wounded.
- Woody discusses Vang's claim of self-defense and the testimony of surviving hunters.
- The episode identifies the victims and describes the resulting trial.
- Vang was convicted in 2005 and sentenced to six consecutive life terms, along with additional prison time.
- Woody reports that Vang died in prison on June 10, 2026.
- The episode includes a news audio excerpt about Vang's death and the original shooting.
Susan Smith — The 1994 Murders of Michael and Alex
- Woody recalls hearing reports about the disappearance of Susan Smith's children while working in North Carolina.
- On October 25, 1994, Smith claimed that a man had carjacked her vehicle with her two sons inside.
- Her account sparked a nationwide search lasting nine days.
- Smith eventually confessed to allowing her vehicle to roll into John D. Long Lake.
- Her sons, three-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex, were still restrained in their car seats.
- Investigators recovered the vehicle and the children's bodies.
- Prosecutors argued that Smith killed the boys because a romantic partner did not want children.
- The defense raised issues involving depression, childhood trauma, and an alleged murder-suicide intention.
- A jury convicted Smith of two counts of murder in July 1995.
- She received a life sentence with parole eligibility after 30 years.
The Lasting Impact on David Smith
- Woody plays an interview with Tommy Pope, the former prosecutor in the Susan Smith case.
- Pope discusses the effect of repeated parole hearings on David Smith, the boys' father.
- He explains that the original jury believed a life sentence would mean Smith would remain incarcerated for the rest of her life.
- Pope describes David's continuing grief and his commitment to preserving the memory of Michael and Alex.
- The discussion emphasizes how parole proceedings can reopen emotional wounds for victims' families.
- Woody expresses support for David Smith's opposition to parole.
Susan Smith's Prison Disciplinary History
Woody examines reported violations and misconduct during Smith's incarceration:
- 2000–2001: Improper sexual relationships involving correctional officers Houston Cagle and Alfred Rowe Jr., both of whom faced consequences.
- 2010 and 2015: Drug-related institutional disciplinary violations.
- 2010: A disciplinary infraction categorized as self-mutilation.
- 2012: Unauthorized use of another inmate's personal identification number.
- 2024: Unauthorized communications involving a documentary filmmaker and discussion of the murders.
- Woody discusses the restrictions imposed following these incidents, including loss of telephone, canteen, and entertainment privileges.
- He questions whether Smith's prison conduct demonstrates rehabilitation or accountability.
The 2024 and 2026 Parole Decisions
- Smith became eligible for parole after serving approximately 30 years.
- Her first parole request was denied in 2024.
- Woody reports that the South Carolina parole authorities denied her second request on November 19, 2026.
- The episode attributes the denial to the severity of the crimes and concerns about her institutional behavior.
- Smith remains eligible to seek parole again in two years.
- Woody argues that her original life sentence should mean she remains incarcerated permanently.
Parole Hearing Testimony
The episode includes audio excerpts from individuals speaking in support of Susan Smith.
Cindy Stone — Former Correctional Officer
- Stone describes working with Smith for approximately 15 years.
- She says she developed a relationship of trust with Smith and continued communicating with her after retirement.
- Stone describes Smith as remorseful and supportive of other incarcerated women.
- She asks the parole board to consider Smith as a person beyond the public portrayal of her crimes.
- Woody disputes Stone's assessment and questions the appropriateness of her personal relationship with a former inmate.
Susan Smith's Family
- Family members speak about Smith's childhood, the death of her father, and her personal development during incarceration.
- They describe their belief that she has changed and express willingness to support her if released.
- Woody acknowledges that family members may continue to love someone who has committed terrible crimes but strongly disagrees with their support for parole.
Woody's Reaction to the Testimony
- Woody questions the statements made in support of Smith.
- He challenges the suggestion that her behavior in prison establishes meaningful rehabilitation.
- He revisits the original murders and Smith's false carjacking account.
- Woody discusses the racial implications of falsely accusing a Black man of abducting her children.
- He expresses outrage that Smith remains eligible for release despite the murders of Michael and Alex.
Closing — Remember Michael and Alex
- Woody returns to the suffering of the two children and the lasting impact on their father.
- He emphasizes that the victims, rather than the person convicted of killing them, deserve continued public attention.
- He closes with his strong opposition to Smith's release and thanks the Lifers for listening.
Real Life Real Crime — True Crime Time
Justice for victims. Never give up. Never surrender.
Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp and use my code betterhelp.com for a great deal: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com
* Check out Stio and use my code stio.com/RLRC for a great deal: https://www.stio.com
* Check out TruDiagnostic and use my code RLRC for a great deal: https://www.trudiagnostic.com
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy