← Real Life Real Crime
Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp and use my code betterhelp.com for a great deal: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com
* Check out Stio and use my code stio.com/RLRC for a great deal: https://www.stio.com
* Check out TruDiagnostic and use my code RLRC for a great deal: https://www.trudiagnostic.com
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacySee all episodes

Real Life Real Crime | Justice for Hailey: A Breakthrough in the Fight for Answers
20 Nov 2026 · 40:10
The Long Fight for Justice for Hailey
- Woody revisits the years-long effort to obtain justice for Hailey and her mother, Barbara Johnson.
- He recalls the original Real Life Real Crime investigative series and the Lifers' involvement in bringing attention to the case.
- Woody discusses how the campaign ultimately led to a meeting between Barbara Johnson, her family, and the Cobb County District Attorney's Office.
- He recounts assurances that the case would receive serious attention from a senior investigator.
- Woody explains how months passed without the progress the family had hoped for.
The District Attorney's Office and the Demand for Scientific Evidence
- Barbara Johnson continues pressing the district attorney's office for answers.
- Woody describes a subsequent meeting in which prosecutors indicated that additional scientific evidence would be necessary before they would reconsider prosecution.
- He expresses frustration with what he describes as changing explanations for the decision not to pursue the case.
- Woody announces plans to replay earlier recordings and episodes documenting the family's interactions with prosecutors.
Scott Roder and the Forensic Investigation
- A Lifer helps connect Barbara Johnson with forensic expert Scott Roder.
- Roder and his team undertake an independent examination of the evidence surrounding Hailey's death.
- The analysis requires specialized equipment, scientific modeling, and forensic personnel.
- Approximately $10,000 is needed to support the examination.
- Barbara establishes a GoFundMe campaign, and the Lifers contribute toward the expense.
- Attorney Thomas Davenport donates knives for a fundraising raffle to help complete the funding.
- According to Woody, Roder's forensic findings establish that Hailey could not physically have inflicted the fatal shotgun wound herself.
- Woody also references analysis involving bloodstain patterns, body positioning, and other crime-scene evidence.
- Roder communicates with prosecutors and offers to have his findings examined by other qualified experts.
The Double Jeopardy Dispute
- Woody reports that the district attorney's office subsequently cited double jeopardy as a reason not to prosecute Brooks Cleary for Hailey's murder.
- He disputes that explanation and turns to attorney Thomas "Tommy" Davenport Jr. for assistance.
- Woody explains that Cleary's earlier prosecution concerned moving Hailey's body and damaging property at a police station, rather than a murder charge.
- According to Woody, Cleary had not previously been tried for Hailey's murder.
- Woody also revisits concerns about the original death investigation and the medical examiner's determination.
- These are Woody's characterizations of the case and the prosecution's decisions, not independent legal findings.
Thomas Davenport's Legal Memorandum
- Davenport prepares a memorandum examining whether a murder prosecution would be barred by double jeopardy.
- He submits the memorandum and case materials to legal professionals for independent review.
- Woody describes the reviewers as including retired judges, law professors, defense attorneys, and prosecutors.
- According to Woody, the reviewers agreed that double jeopardy would not prevent a murder prosecution.
- Davenport describes the unusual degree of agreement among the reviewers as a "legal unicorn."
- Woody credits Davenport's work with identifying a possible new avenue for review.
A Georgia Review Board
- Through a colleague in Georgia, Davenport learns of a state review process concerning certain district attorney decisions not to prosecute cases.
- Hailey's case materials are submitted for consideration.
- The submission includes information from the original investigation, Roder's forensic work, Davenport's legal analysis, and Barbara Johnson.
- Woody explains that cases must first be evaluated to determine whether they warrant consideration by the board.
- Barbara initially receives little information about the submission's status.
The Major Update — December Review Expected
- Woody reveals that Barbara Johnson has recently received a response from a representative of the review board.
- According to Barbara's account as relayed by Woody, the representative confirms that Hailey's case materials have been received and reviewed.
- The representative reportedly attempted to place the matter before the board in November but was unable to do so because of scheduling.
- Woody reports that the representative expects the case to be presented during the board's December meeting.
- The precise December meeting date is not provided.
- Woody considers this a meaningful development because the case appears to have advanced beyond the initial review stage.
- The episode does not report a new indictment, a scheduled murder trial, or a final board decision.
Recognizing Attorney Thomas "Tommy" Davenport Jr.
- Woody thanks Davenport for the time and legal work he has contributed without charging Barbara Johnson for his assistance.
- He discusses Davenport's background in criminal defense, constitutional law, litigation, and legal education.
- Woody also recognizes Davenport's support staff, particularly Kylie.
- He encourages listeners to support the firm and acknowledges Davenport's commitment to cases involving alleged injustice.
Woody Attempts to Contact Barbara Johnson
- During the recording, Woody calls Barbara in hopes of having her explain the board's latest communication directly.
- Barbara does not answer, and Woody leaves a voicemail.
- He tells her that he is recording the Friday episode and plans to revisit the case throughout Thanksgiving week.
- Woody expresses appreciation for Barbara and the support she has received from the Lifers.
Barbara's Determination and Woody's Regrets
- Woody describes Barbara's frustration and her willingness to protest publicly to demand action.
- He encourages her to continue pursuing the case without risking arrest.
- Woody acknowledges that he previously advised Barbara to give the district attorney's office additional time to investigate.
- He now regrets that advice and accepts responsibility for encouraging patience when the family wanted to press for answers.
- He reflects on the emotional toll of the delays and his continued determination to seek justice.
Thanksgiving Week — Revisiting the Original Hailey Series
- Woody announces plans to replay selected episodes from the original Hailey investigation during Thanksgiving week.
- He intends to revisit the forensic evidence, meetings with prosecutors, recordings of previous discussions, and Davenport's legal analysis.
- The purpose is to familiarize newer listeners with the case and remind longtime Lifers of the issues that remain unresolved.
- Woody also discusses renewing public and media attention as the expected December board review approaches.
Closing — Never Give Up, Never Surrender
- Woody emphasizes that the legal process can move slowly but that continued persistence matters.
- He thanks the Lifers for their financial contributions, advocacy, and ongoing support for Barbara Johnson.
- He reiterates his commitment to pursuing answers in Hailey's case.
- Woody closes with encouragement to remain engaged as the expected December review approaches.
Justice for Hailey. Never give up. Never surrender.
Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp and use my code betterhelp.com for a great deal: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com
* Check out Stio and use my code stio.com/RLRC for a great deal: https://www.stio.com
* Check out TruDiagnostic and use my code RLRC for a great deal: https://www.trudiagnostic.com
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy