Skip to content
← Real Life Real Crime

Real Life Real Crime | Justice for Hailey: A Breakthrough in the Fight for Answers

20 Nov 2026 · 40:10

The Long Fight for Justice for Hailey

  • Woody revisits the years-long effort to obtain justice for Hailey and her mother, Barbara Johnson.
  • He recalls the original Real Life Real Crime investigative series and the Lifers' involvement in bringing attention to the case.
  • Woody discusses how the campaign ultimately led to a meeting between Barbara Johnson, her family, and the Cobb County District Attorney's Office.
  • He recounts assurances that the case would receive serious attention from a senior investigator.
  • Woody explains how months passed without the progress the family had hoped for.

The District Attorney's Office and the Demand for Scientific Evidence

  • Barbara Johnson continues pressing the district attorney's office for answers.
  • Woody describes a subsequent meeting in which prosecutors indicated that additional scientific evidence would be necessary before they would reconsider prosecution.
  • He expresses frustration with what he describes as changing explanations for the decision not to pursue the case.
  • Woody announces plans to replay earlier recordings and episodes documenting the family's interactions with prosecutors.

Scott Roder and the Forensic Investigation

  • A Lifer helps connect Barbara Johnson with forensic expert Scott Roder.
  • Roder and his team undertake an independent examination of the evidence surrounding Hailey's death.
  • The analysis requires specialized equipment, scientific modeling, and forensic personnel.
  • Approximately $10,000 is needed to support the examination.
  • Barbara establishes a GoFundMe campaign, and the Lifers contribute toward the expense.
  • Attorney Thomas Davenport donates knives for a fundraising raffle to help complete the funding.
  • According to Woody, Roder's forensic findings establish that Hailey could not physically have inflicted the fatal shotgun wound herself.
  • Woody also references analysis involving bloodstain patterns, body positioning, and other crime-scene evidence.
  • Roder communicates with prosecutors and offers to have his findings examined by other qualified experts.

The Double Jeopardy Dispute

  • Woody reports that the district attorney's office subsequently cited double jeopardy as a reason not to prosecute Brooks Cleary for Hailey's murder.
  • He disputes that explanation and turns to attorney Thomas "Tommy" Davenport Jr. for assistance.
  • Woody explains that Cleary's earlier prosecution concerned moving Hailey's body and damaging property at a police station, rather than a murder charge.
  • According to Woody, Cleary had not previously been tried for Hailey's murder.
  • Woody also revisits concerns about the original death investigation and the medical examiner's determination.
  • These are Woody's characterizations of the case and the prosecution's decisions, not independent legal findings.

Thomas Davenport's Legal Memorandum

  • Davenport prepares a memorandum examining whether a murder prosecution would be barred by double jeopardy.
  • He submits the memorandum and case materials to legal professionals for independent review.
  • Woody describes the reviewers as including retired judges, law professors, defense attorneys, and prosecutors.
  • According to Woody, the reviewers agreed that double jeopardy would not prevent a murder prosecution.
  • Davenport describes the unusual degree of agreement among the reviewers as a "legal unicorn."
  • Woody credits Davenport's work with identifying a possible new avenue for review.

A Georgia Review Board

  • Through a colleague in Georgia, Davenport learns of a state review process concerning certain district attorney decisions not to prosecute cases.
  • Hailey's case materials are submitted for consideration.
  • The submission includes information from the original investigation, Roder's forensic work, Davenport's legal analysis, and Barbara Johnson.
  • Woody explains that cases must first be evaluated to determine whether they warrant consideration by the board.
  • Barbara initially receives little information about the submission's status.

The Major Update — December Review Expected

  • Woody reveals that Barbara Johnson has recently received a response from a representative of the review board.
  • According to Barbara's account as relayed by Woody, the representative confirms that Hailey's case materials have been received and reviewed.
  • The representative reportedly attempted to place the matter before the board in November but was unable to do so because of scheduling.
  • Woody reports that the representative expects the case to be presented during the board's December meeting.
  • The precise December meeting date is not provided.
  • Woody considers this a meaningful development because the case appears to have advanced beyond the initial review stage.
  • The episode does not report a new indictment, a scheduled murder trial, or a final board decision.

Recognizing Attorney Thomas "Tommy" Davenport Jr.

  • Woody thanks Davenport for the time and legal work he has contributed without charging Barbara Johnson for his assistance.
  • He discusses Davenport's background in criminal defense, constitutional law, litigation, and legal education.
  • Woody also recognizes Davenport's support staff, particularly Kylie.
  • He encourages listeners to support the firm and acknowledges Davenport's commitment to cases involving alleged injustice.

Woody Attempts to Contact Barbara Johnson

  • During the recording, Woody calls Barbara in hopes of having her explain the board's latest communication directly.
  • Barbara does not answer, and Woody leaves a voicemail.
  • He tells her that he is recording the Friday episode and plans to revisit the case throughout Thanksgiving week.
  • Woody expresses appreciation for Barbara and the support she has received from the Lifers.

Barbara's Determination and Woody's Regrets

  • Woody describes Barbara's frustration and her willingness to protest publicly to demand action.
  • He encourages her to continue pursuing the case without risking arrest.
  • Woody acknowledges that he previously advised Barbara to give the district attorney's office additional time to investigate.
  • He now regrets that advice and accepts responsibility for encouraging patience when the family wanted to press for answers.
  • He reflects on the emotional toll of the delays and his continued determination to seek justice.

Thanksgiving Week — Revisiting the Original Hailey Series

  • Woody announces plans to replay selected episodes from the original Hailey investigation during Thanksgiving week.
  • He intends to revisit the forensic evidence, meetings with prosecutors, recordings of previous discussions, and Davenport's legal analysis.
  • The purpose is to familiarize newer listeners with the case and remind longtime Lifers of the issues that remain unresolved.
  • Woody also discusses renewing public and media attention as the expected December board review approaches.

Closing — Never Give Up, Never Surrender

  • Woody emphasizes that the legal process can move slowly but that continued persistence matters.
  • He thanks the Lifers for their financial contributions, advocacy, and ongoing support for Barbara Johnson.
  • He reiterates his commitment to pursuing answers in Hailey's case.
  • Woody closes with encouragement to remain engaged as the expected December review approaches.

Justice for Hailey. Never give up. Never surrender.



Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp and use my code betterhelp.com for a great deal: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com
* Check out Stio and use my code stio.com/RLRC for a great deal: https://www.stio.com
* Check out TruDiagnostic and use my code RLRC for a great deal: https://www.trudiagnostic.com


Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
See all episodes

Podfire uses the open podcast catalogue from Podcast Index. Powered by Podcast Index.

Podfire is operated by Media8 Pty Ltd, ABN 89 646 595 280.

Real Life Real Crime | Justice for Hailey: A Breakthrough in the Fight for Answers · Podfire